Tiny Treats

⋆🥧⋆

Big Flavor

⋆🥧⋆

Tiny Treats ⋆🥧⋆ Big Flavor ⋆🥧⋆

About/FAQ

Here you’ll find a little about what happens here at Tiny Crust Co. If you’re still wondering about something, just reach out - always happy to help!

Tiny Crust Co. is a small, home-based bakery tucked right here in Stillwater, Oklahoma.

Everything we make is baked in small batches inside our cozy kitchen - no machines, no shortcuts, just real ingredients and lots of love.

Tiny Crust Co. specializes in 3-inch mini pies, soft breads, and nostalgic sweets that feel like something you’d find cooling on a windowsill. Every pie is hand-pinched, every filling is made from scratch, and every order is baked fresh just for you.

All baked goods are made with care by a ServSafe certified food handler and follow Oklahoma’s cottage food laws so you always know exactly where your treats come from - and exactly what’s in every bite.

If you love small comforts, warm flavors, and desserts with personality, you’re in the right place.

Tiny Treats, Big Flavor - welcome to Tiny Crust Company! <3🥧

Alongside Tiny Crust Co., I also create original artwork!

View artwork →

Your Questions, Answered

  • We currently offer six mini pie flavors:

    • Sweet Egg Custard

    • Key Lime

    • Apple Caramel Crumble

    • Mixed Berry Crumble

    • Spiced Chai Pumpkin

    • Pistachio Fluff

    Seasonal flavors may pop up throughout the year!

    With both the half dozen & one dozen mini pie boxes, you can select up to 3 different flavors.

  • 24 hours in advance is perfect for most items. Bigger orders may need a little more time - just reach out!

  • We offer both porch pickup and delivery options.

    For porch pickup, we will send you the address after the order is ready!

    For delivery, select the ‘delivery’ option at checkout! We deliver anywhere within Stillwater city limits.

    If you place a delivery outside of city limits, we will refund the $5 delivery charge and confirm you are able to pick up the order from our personal address.

  • If you need to cancel, please reach out as soon as possible. Orders already baked can’t be refunded.

  • If we can make it happen, we will! Just contact us.

  • Not directly on the website, but you can always send a message for a custom order and we can make it happen!